Blog

Reconsider 3 (left) Boundless (right)

In the fall of 2019 through early 2020, I wove five small tapestries, all designed in Photoshop, all collaging a variety of source materials in order to come up with the final design. I am going to explain my design process for two of those, Reconsider 3 and Boundless.

Reconsider 3

These details from two historical, Andean textiles are the source materials for Reconsider 3’s design. They portray a bird motif (above left) and a geometric motif (above right).

The above left image is a screenshot of Photoshop’s Layers menu. It shows that there are three layers in this design. Layers are a fundamental aspect of Photoshop. Anything you introduce into the Photoshop file can become its own layer, which can be manipulated in many ways. They can be altered, joined with other layers, interact with other layers, and much more. The order of the layers is important because it governs which layers can interact with each other. The screenshot of the Layers menu shows that the bird motif textile sits on top of the geometric motif textile. A background layer, which is solid white, sits underneath the other two layers. The image on the right is a screenshot of the Blending Options menu. Blending bleeds images into each other in specific value ranges. Each layer can be blended with the layer below and/or above it. The screenshot shows the blending settings for the bird motif textile, which is the top layer. It is set so that the underlying layer – the one with the geometric motif – will bleed through in the darker values of the bird motif textile.    

The white areas in the above left image are where the darker values in the bird motif textile were and where the underlying geometric motif textile will show through. In the middle is the composite, blended Photoshop image, the design for Reconsider 3. On the right is the completed tapestry.

Boundless

Boundless is two separate tapestries mounted together. The top tapestry follows the line of investigation I was pursuing in designing Reconsider 3. The bottom tapestry introduces the title of the piece, although the cropping and the text dissolving into the background makes reading it elusive.

The source materials for Boundless are a detail from a kilim (above left) and a detail from an Andean textile (above right). 

The screenshot (above left) shows that there are 16 layers in the Photoshop file. This is quite a few more than in Reconsider 3 but most of them are just setting up the repeat of the detail from the Andean textile. The right image shows the repeated pattern – two columns of seven. The Layers menu shows that the kilim sits on top of the 14 repeats. A white background layer is the 16th layer.

You can see those areas in the image, below left. They are a gray checkerboard. In addition, the underlying layer – the 14 repeated elements – is set to bleed into the upper kilim layer in its lighter values. It is the combination of these two settings that produces the finished composition, the design for the top section of Boundless (below middle). The tapestry is below right.

Since I have been working with this method of designing, I have been trying, true to my systematic nature, to figure out how to predict how two different images are going to blend together. I can’t say I have been entirely successful. I have been able to identify certain characteristics that make for interesting blending, but I am constantly surprised by what happens when I start playing around with the blending options. Sometimes magic happens and sometimes it doesn’t. I have many, many experiments that have not led to anything I find interesting. But that is often the case with designing, no matter what kind of process you employ. A lot of experimentation is often required, working and reworking, to come up with a successful image. 

The part of Boundless that contains the title of the piece involves a simpler kind of blending, one that controls the opacity of a layer across the entire image. There are different ways that the blending can happen. In this case the diffuse option makes the lettering merge into the blue background.

An earlier version of this article was published in the Tapestry Weavers West newsletter.

Recently, my regional tapestry group, Tapestry Artists of Puget Sound, began a group project in which each of us would weave a tapestry, or maybe more than one tapestry, that was inspired by an existing textile. Beyond that, there were no other stipulations. The chosen textile would serve as a springboard for a design that could evolve in any direction that caught our attention.  Because I often use references to historical textiles, or even incorporate details out of historical textiles, into my tapestry designs, I engaged with the project easily.

Borrowed Language 1 source textile – Andean

(left) Borrowed Language 1 design. (right) Borrowed Language 1, tapestry, 12”x8,” 2024, cotton warp, wool weft. Photo: Mary Lane

I excerpted motifs from the Andean textile, altered them a bit and arranged them in a variety of patterned compositions until I came up with something that I liked. Because I saw the different motifs and shapes as weaving language, I called the piece Borrowed Language 1.

In this tapestry I reengaged with a feature of weaving patterns that I had explored a few years ago in weavings that I called Woodles – woven doodles – borrowing this term from Kennita Tully. The feature of weaving patterns that I refer to, is the fact that, to weave patterns,  the number of warp threads needed for each element must be calculated so that the repeats fit within the width of the tapestry and the number of warp threads contained in that width. Or, conversely, one can let the number of warp threads needed to weave the repeats of the patterns determine the width of the tapestry.

Because I did not want to weave on single warps, I assigned each vertical line two warps. Given the intended size of my tapestry, this meant that I had room for four repeats of the gold motif, instead of the six repeats that are in the Photoshop design. I altered the white motif, as well, so that I could fit entire repeats of the motif within the number of warps I had available. I find that thinking within the constraints of a pattern – calculating the number of warps needed to weave it, or altering a pattern in order to weave it with the number of warps upon which you have already decided, to be a great mental exercise.

(left) Borrowed Language 2, design. (right) Borrowed Language 2, tapestry, 12”x8,” 2024, cotton warp, wool and cotton warp weft. Photo: Mary Lane

In Borrowed Language 2,  I wove the red background with boucle yarn and the patterns with cotton embroidery floss so that the material differences in the two yarns became an additional feature of the tapestry.

As I alluded to, this project was interesting to me because I enjoy looking at, thinking about and riffing off historical textiles. I may weave a few more pieces for this project. I worked up some potential designs with the Borrowed Language series in mind, but instead of creating them in Photoshop, I drew them with markers or colored pencils.

(left) Gabriela Cristu (Romania) Prelude to the Afternoon of a Faun, 59″x72″
(right) Liev Beuten-Schellekens (Belgium), Imagination, 51″x53.5″

Several people have asked how I developed the design for my most recent tapestry, Wander. I’ll make a stab at explaining it here.

My most recent work (see Boundless and the Reconsider series here) references historical textiles through the incorporation of borrowed patterns, motifs and/or details from actual historical tapestries. The textile excerpts are combined with each other, and with other image sources, such as drawings or photographs, to produce a layered image in which the different components are merged together into one blended image.

Wander combines details from an Andean textile showing a pattern of Brockett deer, a photograph of rocks, a drawing of birds in flight and a pattern from a Berber carpet. The diagonals in the rug pattern and the flying birds suggested the title Wander, which I incorporated as text into the tapestry.

The design is collaged, layered and blended in Photoshop. It went through 27 different morphs along the path to its resolution. The final version has 14 layers.

One layer is an Andean tapestry depicting a pattern of Brockett deer. Two layers are themselves collages of different parts of a drawing of flying crows.

Five layers are a detail from a Berber carpet repeated. Two of the layers are the text in the image.

One layer is the rock layer. The rock layer is a crop from a rock wall which I then altered with the Cutout Filter in Photoshop. Two layers make up the bottom section of the tapestry. They are a crop from the rock layer repeated – first right side up and then upside down.

The last layer is the background, which is a dark grey.

I used the Blend If and Dissolve functions in Photoshop to merge the different layers together. Dissolve bleeds images into one another. You can control the degree to which they bleed but the bleed is the same across the entire image. That works well for certain situations. For example, I used the Dissolve function to merge the text into the Berber carpet. The Blend If function allows for a more sophisticated merging of images. You can control the amount that the top layer bleeds into the bottom layer (or the bottom layer bleeds into the top layer) at different points along the value scale. So, for example, the Brockett deer tapestry bleeds through the rock layer only in the darkest value. Positioning the layers with respect to each other is critical in controlling which layer bleeds through to another. The possibilities are mind boggling and that is why I had 27 renditions of the image. I usualy find it is very hard to decide that an image is finished.

Another reason I had so many versions of this design is that I took Gerhardt Knodel’s class, Mining Historic Textiles as a Route to the Future, when I was working on this design. You can read about my experience in that class on Ellen Ramsey’s blog. Before the class, the design was just the section above the Berber carpet. Gerhardt talked about creating disruptions in designs and it was that thought that inspired me to work more on this design, adding the carpet pattern, text, and repeated section on the bottom.

Just in case you are interested, this is what the interface looks like for one of the text layers of this particular design.

I enjoyed weaving this tapestry. It was scaled well for the size, 53″ x 30,” and warp sett, 8 ends per inch. There was a lot of “noise” in the image – little dots of color. I like to strike a balance between blended colors (different colors in the weft bundle) and colors that are solid. Because the colors in the background and the section with the Berber carpet were quite variegated, I made the colors of the birds and the Brockett deer tapestry flatter than they were in the design. I used hachures and battage to blend the colors in the background and to create the patterns in the Berber carpet.

I am working on several more designs using this design process and I look forward to finishing one for my next tapestry.